Birch has been my favorite for several years and I have ordered it repeatedly. The OLD Birch. I do know the scent hasn’t been as strong or lasted as long since you stopped putting actual lids on Birch, but rather a fitted piece of thin cardboard or the basic formula has changed since the original octagonal jars.
I also became aware of Whiskey and in my recent order, ordered two Birch and one Barrel-Aged Whiskey. Unfortunately, I only received one Birch, the second one having been replaced with Wood and Smoke or something, which I didn’t order. I was surprised that if stock was low, at least a second Barrel-Aged Whiskey wasn’t the substitute.
Overall, I still like Birch but my last order was odd to say the least.